Contents
Chapter Thirty-Four: Halle
Overview
An unexpected family visit forces Halle into a confrontation with Will, whose criticism prompts her to expose their one-sided friendship and end it explicitly. Will retaliates by attacking Halle’s confidence in Henry and her new friends, leaving her reluctant to seek their support. Her parents’ assumption that they can stay without asking further highlights the expectations surrounding Halle’s habitual willingness to accommodate others.
Summary
Halle discovers that her parents, Will, and Will’s parents have arrived a day early because Will’s coach allowed him to travel ahead of the game. Overwhelmed by their unannounced presence, Halle messages her friends for support. Wearing Henry’s team shirt and still carrying traces of their painting session, Halle rushes upstairs to hide a box of condoms, only to find it empty. During a playful text exchange with Henry, Halle mentions her parents’ early arrival but does not tell him Will is there.
Outside the bathroom, Will asks to speak privately in Halle’s bedroom, but Halle refuses. Will initially eases the tension by explaining that he did not know the visit would surprise her. However, Will then questions Halle about her supposed boyfriend, referring to the condoms and Henry’s name on her shirt. Halle ends the conversation and, after disposing of the empty box, concludes that Will was responsible for its missing contents.
Will continues confronting Halle in the hallway, criticizing changes in her appearance, social life, and sexual activity. When Will asks why Halle never put him first, Halle lists years of prioritizing his needs, including helping with schoolwork, driving, providing alibis, and babysitting. Halle explains that their friendship depended on her inability to say no and challenges Will to name something he likes about her unrelated to helping others. Will offers no answer.
Instead, Will claims Halle’s new friends will abandon her when Henry loses interest and makes a cruel comparison between Henry’s sexual relationship with Halle and their own past relationship. Halle explicitly ends their friendship and orders Will to leave. Will dismisses her anger and insists he will restore their friendship during spring break, but eventually leaves. Shaken, Halle considers contacting Henry or her friends, then holds back because she does not want to disrupt Henry’s game preparation and fears Will’s predictions could be true.
Returning downstairs, Halle learns that her younger sisters stayed behind and that her mother and stepfather intend to stay in the house without having asked. Halle objects briefly but yields when her mother dismisses the conflict with Halle’s plans. Will’s mother then picks up Henry’s sketchbook, and Halle’s mother examines its many drawings of Halle. Will’s parents leave, followed by Halle’s parents retiring for the night, leaving Halle wishing Joy could explain how much better Henry treats her than Will did.
Who Appears
- Halle JacobsConfronts Will’s exploitation, ends their friendship, and struggles with doubts and her parents’ disregard for her boundaries.
- WillCriticizes Halle’s independence, belittles her relationships, and dismisses her decision to end their friendship.
- Halle’s motherArrives unannounced, assumes she can stay, and examines Henry’s sketchbook filled with drawings of Halle.
- Henry TurnerExchanges affectionate texts with Halle, unaware of Will’s presence and the subsequent confrontation.
- PaulHalle’s stepfather, accompanying her mother on the surprise visit and offering Halle familiar affection before bed.
- Will’s motherJoins the unexpected gathering and draws attention to Henry’s sketchbook.
- Will’s fatherRecognizes the uncomfortable atmosphere and suggests leaving for the hotel.
- Poppy GrantOffers humor and encouragement through the group chat during Halle’s unexpected encounter with Will.
- Cami WalkerUrges Halle to escape and cautions that telling Henry could bring him into the confrontation.
- Emilia BennettOffers to rescue Halle and asks whether she has told Henry about the visitors.
- Aurora RobertsOffers Halle a hotel escape and joins the friends’ teasing attempts to support her.