Contents
Chapter One: Halle
Overview
Halle accepts the end of a yearlong relationship with childhood friend Will, but their breakup becomes painful when Will criticizes Halle’s sexual boundaries, reading, and lack of independent friendships. The conversation reveals how much Halle sacrificed to sustain an incompatible relationship and avoid loneliness. Recognizing a broader pattern of putting others first, Halle resolves to spend junior year prioritizing herself.
Summary
In Halle’s kitchen in Los Angeles, Will Ellington ends their yearlong relationship. Halle feels little heartbreak and agrees they are better as friends, but Will is upset that Halle does not seem devastated. Their conversation exposes the difference between Halle’s affection for a longtime friend and the romantic love Halle hoped would develop.
Halle recalls meeting Will after moving to Arizona ten years earlier, when their families became close neighbors. Their friendship became romantic after a drunken kiss at a wedding the previous summer, encouraged by their parents’ enthusiasm. Halle initially felt flattered by Will’s interest, but physical intimacy brought discomfort rather than attraction. Despite those doubts, Halle kept trying to make the relationship work.
Back in the kitchen, Will accuses Halle of being too much of a people pleaser to initiate the breakup. Will makes a hurtful sexual remark and claims to have been unusually patient about Halle’s unwillingness to have sex. Halle rejects the suggestion that an adult relationship requires sex and recognizes that the breakup follows another refusal the previous night. Their differing ambitions and Halle’s fear of loneliness further explain why an unsuitable relationship lasted so long.
To reduce anticipated pressure from their families, Halle offers to describe the breakup as mutual and spend Christmas with Halle’s father and Shannon. Will then asks Halle to stop attending his hockey games, despite having pressured Halle to abandon a book club and rearrange classes to attend them. When Halle expresses concern about their shared friends taking sides, Will reveals that his college friends encouraged the breakup and says they were never truly Halle’s friends.
Will belittles Halle’s reading and blames fictional romances for their relationship problems, prompting Halle to ask Will to leave. As Will talks about prioritizing himself, Halle recognizes a lifelong pattern of sacrificing personal needs for family, friends, and others. Facing junior year without an independent friend group and with a schedule organized around Will, Halle resolves to stop being a passenger in life and begin making choices for herself.
Who Appears
- HalleAspiring author who accepts a breakup, confronts lifelong people pleasing, and resolves to prioritize her own life.
- Will EllingtonHalle’s longtime friend and hockey-playing boyfriend, whose breakup turns cruel as he attacks Halle’s boundaries and insecurities.