Harry Potter, #5
Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix
by J.K. Rowling
Contents
The Hogwarts High Inquisitor
Overview
The Ministry appoints Dolores Umbridge as Hogwarts High Inquisitor, granting her power to inspect and judge teachers. Umbridge belittles Trelawney, clashes indirectly with McGonagall, and probes Care of Magical Creatures, earning Harry another detention. Under mounting repression and inadequate Defense lessons, Hermione proposes a student-run group with Harry teaching, planting the seed for organized resistance.
Summary
The Daily Prophet announces Educational Decree Twenty-three: Dolores Umbridge is appointed Hogwarts High Inquisitor with authority to inspect teachers. Hermione reads the article aloud, citing Ministry overreach and support from figures like Percy Weasley and Lucius Malfoy. Ron anticipates Umbridge clashing with McGonagall, while classes proceed with heightened tension and harsh O.W.L.-standard marking from Snape.
Umbridge inspects Divination, pressing Trelawney to make a prediction and recording critical notes. In Defense Against the Dark Arts, Umbridge orders silent reading; when Hermione challenges Slinkhard’s views, Umbridge penalizes her. Harry retorts about Quirrell-Voldemort and receives another week of detentions with the blood quill.
Angelina publicly berates Harry for missing practices; McGonagall intervenes, warns Harry about his temper, and deducts points, which angers him. In Transfiguration, Umbridge repeatedly “hem-hems,” but McGonagall pointedly continues teaching advanced Vanishing and coolly dismisses the interruption, showcasing resistance to Umbridge’s authority.
Later, Umbridge inspects Care of Magical Creatures with Grubbly-Plank. She probes Hagrid’s absence and solicits negative accounts; Malfoy cites his hippogriff injury, prompting Harry to defend Hagrid and earn yet another detention. Umbridge departs, satisfied with Grubbly-Plank’s conventional syllabus.
After a painful detention, Harry returns to the common room, where Hermione treats his hand with murtlap essence. Discussing Umbridge’s useless Defense curriculum, Hermione proposes that students learn practical defense themselves, with Harry as teacher. Harry protests, calling his past victories luck, erupts over the reality of facing Voldemort, then calms when Hermione says his experience is exactly what they need. He agrees to think about leading the group as his scar prickles again that night.
Who Appears
- Dolores UmbridgeAppointed High Inquisitor; inspects classes, undermines teachers, assigns Harry further detentions, and probes Hagrid’s absence.
- Harry PotterResents Umbridge, earns more detentions, defends Hagrid, suffers blood-quill injury, and is asked to teach practical Defense.
- Hermione GrangerReads the decree, challenges Slinkhard’s views, tends Harry’s hand, and proposes Harry lead a student Defense group.
- Ron WeasleySupports Hermione’s plan, prompts Harry to see his experience, and worries about homework and Quidditch consequences.
- Professor McGonagallFirmly rebuffs Umbridge during inspection, continues advanced teaching, warns Harry to control his temper.
- Professor TrelawneyFlustered by Umbridge’s inspection; offers a vague prediction and publicly over-interprets Harry’s dream diary.
- Professor Grubbly-PlankSubstitute for Hagrid; presents O.W.L.-focused creatures and impresses Umbridge with conventional methods.
- Angelina JohnsonQuidditch captain; furious at Harry’s missed practices due to detentions, drawing McGonagall’s reprimand.
- Draco MalfoyEager to disparage Hagrid; cites his hippogriff injury to Umbridge during the inspection.