Between Two Fires
by Christopher Buehlman
Contents
One: Of the Donkey
Overview
In plague-stricken Normandy, four desperate soldiers slaughter a donkey and meet a village girl seeking help burying her father. Their leader, Godefroy, tries to assault her, prompting Thomas to kill him and another brigand. At the girl's insistence, Thomas spares Jacquot, signaling a moral shift amid the chaos.
Summary
In a Normandy valley devastated by the Great Death, four ragged former soldiers find a lame donkey on a Friday and slaughter it for food, taking shelter in a barn as rain begins. A young village girl appears, revealing the donkey was hers and asking the men to help bury her dead father.
Godefroy, the group’s predatory leader, pressures the girl with crude threats, while Thomas, an older, trained knight among them, warns him off. The others hesitate; fear of disease and their own desperation tangle with Godefroy’s intent. The girl, who has seen an angel before, senses danger but remains, pleading for help.
When the girl flees to a tree, Jacquot tracks and coerces her down, rationalizing their brutality. He carries her back toward the barn expecting to deliver her to Godefroy. Instead, he finds Godefroy dying with a smashed skull and the fat soldier decapitated—both cut down by Thomas.
Thomas confronts Jacquot at swordpoint, intending to kill him to prevent retaliation. The girl steps between them and begs for mercy. Thomas lowers his blade and spares Jacquot, warning him, as the rain abruptly stops. The moment marks Thomas’s rejection of Godefroy’s brutality and aligns him, however reluctantly, with the girl’s plea for restraint.
Who Appears
- ThomasOlder, trained knight among brigands; kills Godefroy and the fat soldier to protect the girl; spares Jacquot.
- The girlVillage girl seeking help to bury her father; threatened by the brigands; persuades Thomas to show mercy.
- GodefroyBrigand leader with predatory intent toward the girl; killed by Thomas in the barn.
- JacquotBrigand with a drooping eye; retrieves the girl from a tree; spared by Thomas at the girl’s request.
- The fat oneBrigand who first moved to kill the donkey; slain by Thomas, nearly decapitated, hand severed.
- Angel (vision)Ambiguous figure previously guiding the girl; its absence underscores her vulnerability and faith.