Between Two Fires
by Christopher Buehlman
Contents
Four: Of the Monastery, and of the Best Wine Had in Seven Years
Overview
Thomas and the girl discover a plague-ravaged Cistercian monastery, surviving on herbs and spending a night among the dead. On reaching St. Martin-le-Preux, a priest reveals the bridge is burned and a monstrous river creature devours travelers while the seigneur cowers. After wine and confession refused, Thomas accepts the charge to kill the beast.
Summary
Thomas and the girl march toward Paris, hungry and wary. Their guarded banter gives way to discovery of a small Cistercian monastery while foraging. Inside, Thomas finds the buttery stripped and the dormitory and nave filled with signs of plague and four dead monks. The girl vows silence on the grounds and guides Thomas through the herb garden, preventing him from picking monkshood; they dine on edible greens and flowers before sleeping in the cloisters beneath saints’ statues, waking covered in flowers.
On the road again, they meet a Bruges cloth merchant with guards; both parties keep distance and exchange grim news before parting. Near St. Martin-le-Preux, a crude warning reads “GO BACK,” but they proceed, and a priest emerges, masked by a lantern, to halt them. He confirms the town burned its bridge, yet plague struck both banks. Starvation spreads and bodies were dumped into the river.
The priest recounts a new terror: a vast, serpentine, froglike-mouthed creature in the shallows that drags men from boats, devours fishers, and even took a mule and cart; failed would-be crossers’ remains litter the banks. Townsmen, briefly emboldened, lost courage at the grisly scene. Meanwhile the seigneur barricades himself in his tower with hoarded grain, issuing ignored proclamations.
The priest hosts Thomas with the last cask of excellent Beaune wine sourced via his brother in Avignon, and tries to draw out a knightly pledge. Thomas admits he was dispossessed by a Norman lord and turned outlaw with worse men, declining confession. The priest argues that slaying the river abomination would restore Thomas’s honor. Stung and moved, Thomas quells his despair and vows to kill the creature.
Who Appears
- ThomasDisgraced knight guiding the girl; scavenges a plague-dead monastery; resists confession but, urged by the priest and wine, vows to slay the river monster.
- The girlSilent by vow on monastery grounds; knowledgeable about herbs; shares sparse meals and travels toward Paris with Thomas.
- The priest of St. Martin-le-PreuxLantern-bearing cleric who warns of the burned bridge and river beast, shares papal wine, and presses Thomas to reclaim honor by killing it.
- The river creatureEnormous, serpentine predator with a flat, froglike mouth; devours fishers and travelers, blocking passage where the bridge once stood.
- The seigneurLocal lord hiding in his tower with hoarded grain, issuing futile proclamations while townsfolk starve.
- Cloth merchant from BrugesCautious traveler with family and two guards; trades news with Thomas and moves on.
- Flemish men-at-armsGuards for the merchant; wary of provoking Thomas and avoid confrontation.