Contents
18
Overview
Holden, adrift after his fight with Sally, tries reaching Jane but instead arranges a late drink with Carl Luce. To kill time he endures the Rockettes and a sentimental film, which intensify his contempt for phoniness. Memories of Allie and reflections on D.B.’s war years deepen his isolation and fatalistic talk about war.
Summary
Leaving the skating rink, Holden eats at a drugstore and tries calling Jane Gallagher again, hoping to take her dancing. With no answer, he scans his thin address book—Jane, Mr. Antolini, and his father’s office—and instead calls Carl Luce, an older, intellectual former schoolmate, who agrees to meet him for a 10 p.m. drink at the Wicker Bar.
With hours to fill, Holden goes to Radio City. He watches the Rockettes and a holiday pageant with irritated detachment, picturing performers’ empty routines and dismissing the show’s religiosity as phony. A memory of watching the kettle drummer with Allie briefly warms him, admiring the drummer’s focused sincerity.
Holden then endures a sentimental British amnesia film, mocking its contrived plot and happy ending. A woman beside him cries throughout yet refuses to take her bored child to the bathroom, convincing Holden that people who weep at phony movies are often cruel in real life.
Walking to meet Carl Luce, Holden’s thoughts turn to war. He recalls D.B.’s Army years, hating the military more than combat, and their conversations about books. Holden rejects D.B.’s praise of A Farewell to Arms while admiring The Great Gatsby, and he imagines preferring to sit on an atomic bomb rather than endure another war or military life.
Who Appears
- Holden CaulfieldNarrator; fails to reach Jane, arranges to meet Carl Luce, critiques stage shows and a film, recalls Allie, broods on war and D.B.
- Carl LuceOlder former schoolmate; takes Holden’s call and schedules a 10 p.m. drink at the Wicker Bar.
- Jane GallagherHolden tries calling her again without success; he reminisces about her and her date with Al Pike.
- D.B. CaulfieldHolden’s brother; his Army experience and literary tastes shape Holden’s reflections on war and books.
- Allie CaulfieldHolden’s deceased brother; remembered fondly while recalling the kettle drummer at Radio City.
- Sally HayesPreviously attended the Radio City pageant with Holden; mentioned as appreciating its beauty.
- Al PikeJane’s former date; Holden recalls him as a show-off, despite Jane’s sympathy for him.