Lauren collects herself in the church bathroom after a single shared glance with Nico "Junior" Trocci across the aisle reignites a powerful attraction she hasn't felt in ten years. She reminds herself she can't hide because her grandmother, Nonna Bianchi, expects her at coffee hour, and she reasons the Trocci brothers are unlikely to stay.

Leaving the bathroom, Lauren finds Junior waiting in the hallway. He calls her by her old nickname "Lo" and, when she tries to walk past, pins her wrists to the wall while his brother Alec blocks the corridor entrance like a guard. Lauren is torn between arousal and anger, recalling how Junior abandoned her years ago after some incident that forced her to switch schools, leaving her to handle the fallout alone.

Junior taunts her, noting her body's response, and whispers that in high school she would have begged for his touch. Enraged, Lauren attempts to knee him in the groin; he dodges but loosens his grip enough for her to escape. She pulls a taser on Alec, who steps aside with a grin, and rejoins her grandmother. Nonna senses something is wrong and offers to enlist Junior's mother Moira to discipline them, but Lauren brushes it off.

At coffee hour, the elderly women speculate wildly about Lauren's father Tommy's disappearance—Florida, the Feds, or death—while Lauren reflects that Tommy was never a real father; Nonna raised her and her sister Kristen. Junior and Alec leave shortly after the hallway encounter.

Returning home, Lauren is greeted by her dog Walter and roommates Ryan and Taylor. She tells them Junior was at church; Ryan, who knows the history, goes to make mimosas before she retells the story. As Lauren heads upstairs, Nonna calls to make sure she wasn't harmed, reporting that someone slashed multiple tires in the church parking lot.