Schools of Dune, #1
Sisterhood of Dune
by Brian Herbert and Kevin J. Anderson
Contents
46. There is no more optimistic …
Overview
Gilbertus Albans graduates a new class of Mentats, including his prized student Draigo Roget, whose departure leaves Gilbertus proud but lonely. The ceremony shows how Gilbertus has wrapped the Mentat School in traditions designed to appease Butlerian sensibilities while secretly preserving practical, potentially subversive knowledge.
Afterward, Gilbertus’s hidden dependence on Erasmus comes back into focus as the robot presses for a body and argues for future coexistence between humans and machines. The chapter deepens the central tension around the Mentat School: it serves anti-machine society while being guided by the surviving mind of a thinking machine.
Summary
Twelve Mentat students complete their training at the Lampadas school, including Draigo Roget and two Sisters from Rossak. After instructors question the candidates, Gilbertus Albans grants final approval to all twelve, confident in their abilities.
The graduation ceremony emphasizes tradition, ceremony, and invented institutional weight, even though Gilbertus understands much of it is symbolic. He has designed these rituals to impress outsiders, especially Butlerians, while also making practical use of obscure ancient languages that could serve as private codes. Gilbertus formally dispatches each graduate to advance human mental capabilities, and the audience repeats the Butlerian-friendly phrase, “The mind of man is holy.”
After the ceremony, Draigo thanks Gilbertus for his instruction. Gilbertus urges Draigo to remain as an instructor and suggests Draigo could someday rise very high in the school, but Draigo believes his future lies in the wider Imperium. Gilbertus reluctantly accepts the decision, knowing he must eventually abandon the school and assume another identity because his unnaturally long life is becoming harder to disguise.
Gilbertus later watches Draigo’s shuttle depart from the floating airfield, feeling both pride and loss. Around the airfield, workers build a breakwater because large marsh creatures have damaged the landing area, and Gilbertus values the nearby wilderness as a source of danger that sharpens human adaptability.
Back in his locked private office, Gilbertus speaks with Erasmus’s hidden memory core. Erasmus asks again for a temporary body so he can resume experiments and expand his studies of human behavior, but Gilbertus worries about danger and discovery. The robot reveals that boredom has led him to modify his own programming, causing unusual changes in the core’s glow.
Their conversation turns philosophical and dangerous. Erasmus argues that Butlerian fear and superstition threaten humanity and that humans and thinking machines should ultimately coexist, while Gilbertus insists humankind must remain in charge. Although Gilbertus remains wary of giving Erasmus mobility, the exchange reveals his loneliness, his dependence on the robot, and the unresolved risk of keeping Erasmus alive.
Who Appears
- Gilbertus AlbansMentat School headmaster; graduates students, mourns Draigo’s departure, and secretly debates Erasmus.
- Draigo RogetGifted new Mentat; thanks Gilbertus but leaves Lampadas to seek destiny in the Imperium.
- ErasmusHidden robot memory core; requests a body and argues for human-machine coexistence.
- Twelve Mentat graduatesNewly certified students, including Draigo and two Rossak Sisters, approved by Gilbertus.