Cover of Creation Lake

Creation Lake

by Rachel Kushner


Genre
Fiction, Thriller, Contemporary, Philosophy
Year
2024
Pages
416
Contents

Chapter 34

Overview

The narrator reviews her dossier on Pascal Balmy, contrasting the wrong photo circulated by journalists with surveillance images from Genoa 2001 and a 2008 Times Square meeting. She recounts how a UK undercover agent, Marc Cutler, betrayed the group to the FBI, then bombed an army recruitment center himself out of love for Pascal's girlfriend. The episode prompted Pascal's retreat from Paris to the Guyenne, and his ex-girlfriend, daughter of a Justice Ministry official, has since returned to bourgeois respectability.

Summary

The narrator describes the scarce public imagery of Pascal Balmy, noting that journalists covering the Times Square incident had circulated a wrong photo of a different man on a jet ski. Her dossier, by contrast, contains genuine images, including one in a Parisian bar where Pascal's haircut mimics Guy Debord's signature 1950s-60s style, suggesting deliberate emulation of the Situationist icon.

She examines a curious baby photo she initially took for Pascal as a toddler, only to later discover it captioned online as Guy Debord, 1932. She speculates that either dossier files were mixed up, Pascal passed it off as his own, or it functions as a borrowed image of universal innocence.

Most adult photos are surveillance shots: Pascal at the 2001 Genoa G8 protests circled amid riot police, and her favorite set, telephoto images of Pascal and fellow climate activists walking down 44th Street in New York in 2008 ahead of a clandestine meeting. Pascal walks hand-in-hand with a petite, deliberately downscaled bourgeois Parisian girlfriend, all unaware they are being photographed.

The narrator reveals the betrayal embedded in the scene: a UK undercover agent walking behind them had tipped off the FBI, claiming the group planned a Times Square terror attack. The agent reported the plan was cancelled (his microphone conveniently failing during the meeting). Days later, an army recruitment center was bombed, injuring no one. Pascal and the girlfriend had already flown back to Paris via Canada, where border agents found Times Square photos in Pascal's backpack; he claimed tourist status. After this episode, Pascal relocated his committed followers from Paris to the Guyenne.

It later emerged that the undercover agent, Marc Cutler (aka Marc White), had bombed the recruitment center himself, acting alone, apparently because he was in love with Pascal's girlfriend. Cutler sued the UK Metropolitan Police for failing to protect him from ultraleft indoctrination and from falling in love. The girlfriend, daughter of a high Justice Ministry official, was scrubbed from French police files, but the narrator identified her: now married to an EU consultant, working at Gallimard, her radical past discarded like her old wool cap.

Who Appears

  • Sadie (the narrator)
    Undercover operative reviewing her dossier on Pascal, analyzing photos and the Times Square episode.
  • Pascal Balmy
    Anarchist leader styled after Guy Debord; subject of surveillance photos; relocated to the Guyenne after Times Square.
  • Marc Cutler (Marc White)
    UK undercover agent who infiltrated the group, tipped off the FBI, and personally bombed the Times Square recruitment center out of unrequited love.
  • Pascal's former girlfriend
    Petite Parisian activist, daughter of a Justice Ministry official, scrubbed from files; now married, working at Gallimard.
  • Guy Debord
    Situationist icon whose hairstyle and possibly baby photo Pascal echoes or appropriates.
© 2026 StoriLuna