Cover of Yesteryear

Yesteryear

by Caro Claire Burke


Genre
Fiction, Contemporary, Horror, Suspense
Year
2026
Pages
400
Contents

Chapter 10

Overview

Natalie recalls her lavish wedding to Caleb and their uncomfortable, inexperienced first night together, sealing her rapid entry into the Mills family. At the reception, her sister suspects she is pregnant. Months later, a glowing, six-months-pregnant Natalie confronts Reena, revels in her perceived victory, quits school, and plans Paris before her daughter’s birth.

Summary

Natalie and Caleb marry at his parents’ California estate, celebrated by hundreds beneath an olive tree. The reception spotlights the Mills family’s wealth and politics as Natalie wearies of donors. Her sister confides she has likely tested positive for pregnancy, while her husband Bryce drinks and behaves erratically.

Leaving the party at midnight, Natalie and Caleb attempt their first sexual experience. Both are virgins and anxious; Caleb struggles to perform, making the consummation awkward but painless for Natalie. The encounter confirms their inexperience and Natalie’s mix of devotion and disappointment.

About a year later, now six months pregnant, Natalie runs into Reena, who is reeling from humiliations in her dating life and facing a grueling McKinsey internship. Natalie, radiant and self-satisfied, contrasts her happiness with Reena’s dread, mentally condemning Reena’s path.

Emboldened, Natalie announces she is leaving school as Caleb graduates, planning time in Paris before their baby—revealed to be a girl—arrives. The moment cements Natalie’s choice of marriage and motherhood over career, and intensifies her rivalry with Reena.

Who Appears

  • Natalie
    Narrator; marries Caleb, awkwardly consummates, later six months pregnant, quits school, plans Paris.
  • Caleb Mills
    Groom; sexually inexperienced on wedding night; graduating soon; plans Paris with Natalie before baby.
  • Natalie’s sister
    Twenty-one, in emerald bridesmaid dress; suspects pregnancy; worried about Bryce’s drinking.
  • Bryce
    Sister’s husband; drunk and temperamental at the reception; earlier accused theft at hotel.
  • Reena
    Former classmate; humiliated by relationship drama; heading to McKinsey; contrasted with Natalie’s smug happiness.
© 2026 StoriLuna