Cover of It Could Have Been Her

It Could Have Been Her

by Lisa Jewell


Genre
Mystery, Thriller, Suspense, Crime
Pages
384
Contents

Chapter Forty-Three

Overview

Seven years earlier, Stuart describes life with Jessamine’s worsening alcoholism and emotional abuse. A dinner spirals into violence after Stuart defends Daisy, leading to Jessamine’s unhinged accusations and a chilling disavowal. Afterward, Stuart and Daisy bond, and Stuart resolves to cautiously contact Daisy’s estranged father, raising stakes around family secrets and control.

Summary

On a bright February morning, Stuart reflects on how two years with Jessamine have devolved into mutual drinking and despair. He tends to Jessamine, who remains bedridden and denies her alcoholism, while focusing on Daisy’s schooling and planning a visit from his daughter, Blaise. Jessamine fixates on money and resents Stuart’s bond with Daisy.

That evening, Stuart cooks for the family. Jessamine, already drunk, belittles Daisy’s appearance and self-expression. When Stuart defends Daisy, tension spikes. Jessamine escalates, flinging her plate at Stuart and attacking him physically, hurling accusations that he’s fixated on Daisy. Stuart insists Daisy needs care to avoid becoming like Jessamine, provoking another assault. Spent, Jessamine collapses and bitterly declares Daisy is “nothing to do with me,” a chilling disavowal.

Later, Daisy checks on Stuart. He minimizes his injuries but affirms his goal to protect Daisy from further harm. They discuss Blaise, and Daisy’s absent father, who stopped visiting around the time Stuart arrived. Despite Jessamine’s prohibition on contact, Daisy shares an office number.

Stuart offers to speak to Daisy’s father to learn what happened, and Daisy warns him to proceed carefully to avoid worsening Jessamine’s volatility. Stuart resolves to move forward cautiously, signaling a potential shift in family dynamics and sources of control.

Who Appears

  • Stuart
    Narrator; trapped with Jessamine’s alcoholism; defends Daisy; endures a violent attack; decides to contact Daisy’s father.
  • Jessamine
    Severely alcoholic and volatile; mocks Daisy, attacks Stuart, and disavows Daisy after a drunken outburst.
  • Daisy
    Twelve, struggling at school; supported by Stuart; witnesses chaos; hopes to meet Blaise; warns Stuart to be careful.
  • Annie
    Jessamine’s mother; present during dinner, provides sedatives to Jessamine, alarmed by the escalating conflict.
  • Hugo
    House cat; briefly appears, a small normalcy amid household turmoil.
© 2026 StoriLuna