Cover of It Could Have Been Her

It Could Have Been Her

by Lisa Jewell


Genre
Mystery, Thriller, Suspense, Crime
Pages
384
Contents

Chapter Fifty-Five

Overview

Seven years earlier, after Jessamine’s violent attack, Stuart awakens bandaged and effectively imprisoned in a formerly blocked-off au pair room. Jessamine frames the injury as an accident, cites her mother’s stitches, and refuses hospital treatment.

She alternates threats and caretaking, asserting control while Stuart, exhausted and hurt, acquiesces—signaling escalating coercive abuse and family complicity.

Summary

Seven years earlier, Stuart wakes after thirty-six hours to find his ear partially severed, bandaged, and himself in a blocked-off former au pair bedroom. Jessamine claims the injury was accidental, says her mother stitched him to avoid hospital “questions,” and insists he stay put.

When Stuart protests about pain and asks for hospital care, Jessamine denies the need and slaps his hand away from the bandages, reinforcing her control. She reveals the room was sealed after the last au pair left and has been repurposed as “Stuart’s bedroom,” while locking the door behind her despite denying it.

Stuart recalls Jessamine threatening to cut off his other ear with a knife. Jessamine minimizes this as a joke with a butter knife, and pivots to tenderness. She bathes him, controls his movements, and provides caretaking that blurs apology and domination.

Exhausted and hurt, Stuart accepts her ministrations, noting her sobriety and apparent efforts with Daisy as signs of possible change. The scene ends with Stuart momentarily soothed, even affectionate, despite clear coercion, highlighting an abusive cycle enabled by Jessamine and her mother’s involvement.

Who Appears

  • Stuart
    Injured and confined after Jessamine’s attack; seeks hospital care but yields to her control and caretaking.
  • Jessamine
    Violent then contrite; locks Stuart in former au pair room, refuses hospital, cites mother’s stitches, mixes threats with caretaking.
  • Jessamine’s mother
    Off-page but complicit; advises against hospital and stitches Stuart’s ear, enabling Jessamine’s control.
© 2026 StoriLuna