Cover of It Could Have Been Her

It Could Have Been Her

by Lisa Jewell


Genre
Mystery, Thriller, Suspense, Crime
Pages
384
Contents

Chapter Sixty-One

Overview

Stuart describes DI Brooks’s warranted search of Thornwood, which turns up nothing, undermining the investigation. Determined, Stuart privately searches and discovers a photo of a girl. Jane reveals Allen Black once lured her to Thornwood with a likely drugged drink and a scream upstairs, deepening suspicions and stakes around Daisy and Claire.

Summary

Over drinks, Jane presses Stuart to continue his story. Stuart recounts that DI Brooks returned to Thornwood with a warrant: multiple cars, neighbors watching, Annie’s lawyer present. After four hours, the police found nothing, deflating Brooks’s confidence and stalling the case.

Despite the clean search, Stuart felt certain something had been missed. Torn between protecting Daisy and exposing secrets, he hesitated to share more. Jane argued that safeguarding Daisy outweighed collateral damage to Annie and Jessamine, framing the urgency around the abuse and Claire’s family.

Stuart admitted he knew little about Claire Connolly entering the house. Jane then revealed she had been to Thornwood decades earlier, taken there by Allen Black after drinks under the guise of a job. A bang and scream upstairs made her spill a likely drugged drink, prompting her to flee, a near-miss that has haunted her.

Shaken by Jane’s account, Stuart returned to his own actions after the failed search. Convinced Annie had hidden something before the police arrived, he conducted nocturnal searches while Jessamine, Annie, and Daisy slept. After many nights, he finally uncovered something: a photo of a girl.

Who Appears

  • Stuart
    Relates the fruitless police search; later secretly searches Thornwood and finds a photo of a girl; prioritizes protecting Daisy.
  • Jane
    Presses Stuart for truth; reveals Allen Black lured her to Thornwood with a likely drugged drink and a scream upstairs.
  • DI Brooks
    Leads a warranted search of Thornwood; finds nothing, weakening her case.
  • Annie
    Has her lawyer present during the search; suspected by Stuart of hiding something beforehand.
  • Jessamine
    Asleep during Stuart’s nocturnal searches; her secrecy is part of the household’s tension.
  • Daisy
    The child Stuart vows to protect; her safety motivates his search and secrecy.
  • Allen Black
    Years earlier took Jane to Thornwood; likely tried to drug her; associated with a disturbing scream.
  • Claire Connolly
    Missing woman linked to Thornwood; Stuart unsure if she ever entered the property.
© 2026 StoriLuna