Cover of It Could Have Been Her

It Could Have Been Her

by Lisa Jewell


Genre
Mystery, Thriller, Suspense, Crime
Pages
384
Contents

Chapter Five

Overview

In a flashback ten years earlier, Stuart fixates on a woman drinking alone with a small white dog in a Hampstead pub. He approaches and is turned away, then studies her pattern of daytime drinking and deduces she is a mother collecting a child. Stuart’s cool, predatory interest suggests calculated intent, linking the white dog motif to a vulnerable woman.

Summary

In a Hampstead pub at midday on a Tuesday, Stuart notices a neatly dressed woman with a small white dog and immediately reads her drink as a double vodka tonic. He interprets the relief in her eyes as confirmation of a daytime drinking habit and frames her presence in the pub as a tactic to feel less alone.

Stuart takes a pint to her table and politely asks to join her. The woman, wary and defensive, refuses him. He withdraws without pressure, choosing instead to observe from a distance, assessing her appearance, class signals, and unease.

Over the next hours, Stuart watches her order and finish four vodkas. He notes her scuffed, old-fashioned shoes and calculates her likely circumstances: a thirtyish, well-spoken woman who drinks to a schedule.

At 3 p.m., she orders a double espresso, gathers her bag, coat, and the dog, and leaves. Stuart infers her destination is a school gate, masking her habit with coffee and mints before returning home to a partner with a cover story about a dog walk.

He does not follow her but concludes he has “the size of her,” predicting she will return the next day. He intends to be there too, revealing a studied, predatory patience and linking the vulnerable drinker and her white dog to his ongoing interest.

Who Appears

  • Stuart
    Observer-narrator who targets a daytime drinker, assesses her habits, and plans to return.
  • Unnamed woman
    Thirtyish, well-spoken drinker with a white dog; rejects Stuart and leaves for school pickup.
  • White dog (Westie)
    Companion at the pub, reinforcing the woman’s cover story of a dog walk.
© 2026 StoriLuna