Cover of It Could Have Been Her

It Could Have Been Her

by Lisa Jewell


Genre
Mystery, Thriller, Suspense, Crime
Pages
384
Contents

Chapter Sixty-Three

Overview

Jane confronts Stuart about the shackled girl in Jasper’s photos and the outhouse fitted with restraint rings. Stuart says Annie denied everything but he believes Jessamine’s claims about their father’s abuse. Panicked, he begs for time and asks them not to involve the police, refusing to reveal Daisy’s whereabouts.

Summary

Over drinks, Jane presses Stuart about the disturbing photo of a girl in leg shackles. Stuart says he asked Annie, who stonewalled and insisted the girl was merely an au pair and that the shackles were just Jasper’s tricks before the girl left. Stuart contrasts this with Jessamine’s disclosure that their father abused her; Annie flatly denied it, calling Jessamine a fantasist.

Stuart explains he believed Jessamine despite her addictions, and knew Annie was lying but lacked proof. He admits he found nothing further about the girl in the photo or about Claire, leaving him frustrated and still searching for answers.

Jane then raises the outhouse behind Stuart’s kitchen, describing metal rings screwed into the walls that suggest restraints. Stuart first deflects with the lawn-mower story, then grows visibly fearful as Jane insists it was used to hold someone. The tension spikes as Stuart grips Hugo’s lead, drinks quickly, and prepares to leave.

When Jane asks about Daisy’s whereabouts, Stuart cuts her off, pleading that they not go to the police yet and to let him speak to Annie and Jessamine first. He refuses to address Daisy directly, begs for time, and departs with Hugo, leaving Jane and Dexter with heightened suspicion and no immediate resolution.

Who Appears

  • Jane
    Presses Stuart about the shackled girl and outhouse; challenges his explanations; demands Daisy’s whereabouts.
  • Stuart Vale
    Admits Annie denied abuse; believes Jessamine; panics over ouhouse evidence; begs to delay police; withholds Daisy’s location.
  • Annie Vale
    Denies abuse and the photo’s implications; offers au pair cover story; remains a stonewalling obstacle.
  • Jessamine Vale
    Accuses their father of sexual abuse; distrusted by Annie; believed by Stuart despite her addictions.
  • Daisy (Rose)
    Missing and central to Jane’s concerns; Stuart evades revealing her location.
© 2026 StoriLuna