Chapter 34

In the THEN timeline, swimmers discover Billy semi-conscious in bushes at the base of the beach parking-lot stairs. An ambulance takes Billy to Alfred Hospital, where he is placed in an induced coma for a suspected brain injury. With no facts available, rumors spread that Mabel pushed Billy, fueled by claims she loved him and was rejected.

The whispers escalate, recasting Mabel from outcast to potential threat. Daphne stays by Mabel’s side at school, confronting classmates like Eileen and Rosalie and challenging their certainty. Daphne’s loyalty gives Mabel a rare ally amid the vilification.

After school, Mabel and Daphne avoid the beach and go to the library. They greet Ness, then retreat to beanbags in the back. Mabel shares her favorite book, Anne of Green Gables. Remembering Anne and Diana’s pledge, they recite a version of the oath, declaring lifelong friendship, laughing through tears despite shushes from patrons.

Though Mabel’s circumstances are dire and uncertain, the ceremony with Daphne becomes a bright anchor. The moment cements their bond and offers Mabel emotional refuge as suspicion and fear gather around Billy’s accident.