Atlas arrives at Bib’s after a break-in and finds ass whole misspelled in red spray paint on the back door. The insult reminds Atlas of his mother’s way of saying the word, and Darin jokes about whether the vandalism was aimed at Atlas personally because Bib’s is Atlas’s restaurant.

Darin suggests a disgruntled employee may be responsible, and Atlas briefly considers Quartz, a former dishwasher Atlas fired for unsanitary work. Brad then reports that nothing valuable seems missing except the croutons prepared the night before. Because the thief apparently stole food rather than equipment, Atlas decides not to call the police.

Atlas explains that Atlas once broke into a restaurant and stole a turkey sandwich because Atlas was hungry, so Atlas does not want someone arrested for taking croutons. Darin worries that the thief might return or target Atlas’s new restaurant, Corrigan’s, and reminds Atlas that Bib’s security camera is still broken.

Atlas receives a text and immediately hopes it is from Lily, but it is not. Atlas thinks back to running into Lily earlier that morning for the first time in a year and a half. Their brief sidewalk conversation left Atlas hopeful because Lily is no longer married and seemed open to exploring what could be between them, but Lily has not texted as promised.

Atlas opens Lily’s contact information, reflects that Atlas had left the choice to contact him with Lily because her life was complicated, and changes her name in his phone from Lily Kincaid back to Lily Bloom. Darin and Brad notice and ask about Lily, but Atlas shuts down the questions after confirming she had a girl. Atlas then asks if Theo is coming in, deciding that if Atlas discusses Lily with anyone, it will be Theo.