Nathan tells Madeline he cannot simply shut down Abigail’s public website because it is hosted externally and requires Abigail’s login details. Madeline gives him Abigail’s usual password, “Miss Polly had a dolly,” but Nathan has already tried it and explains that Abigail must have changed it after he advised her not to reuse passwords.

Madeline’s anger hardens as she blames Nathan’s advice for making the crisis harder to fix. She begins rapidly listing possible passwords based on Abigail’s childhood, interests, and resentments, including the name of Abigail’s first puppy, but each guess fails. Madeline realizes the password could be anything.

Nathan explains that redirecting the domain or hacking the account would take time, and the fastest solution is for Abigail to remove the site herself. Madeline decides to collect Abigail from school early so they can confront her immediately.

Nathan suggests they should tell Abigail there will be consequences and even proposes grounding her, but Madeline doubts that punishment will work because Abigail sees the plan as a moral cause. Nathan struggles to believe Abigail would actually have sex with a stranger, while Madeline is painfully aware that Abigail would justify it by comparing herself to the exploited girls she wants to help.

Madeline remembers she also needs to pick up the younger children and Perry’s twins because Celeste is sick. Pressed for time and furious, Madeline rejects Nathan’s request that she not yell, declaring that Abigail is selling her virginity on the Internet.