The family continues watching old home videos for Ramsey's documentary. In a Christmas 2007 clip at the old Price & Sons Logging Yard, Rachel holds sleeping baby Bel, whom she calls Anna, while Charlie, Jeff, Sherry, and Grandpa play in the snow. Bel is unsettled to learn that Rachel used a version of Bel's name no one has mentioned to her before.

After the clip, Ramsey questions Charlie about seeing Rachel alive and happy. Charlie explains that seeing Rachel smile makes him instinctively happy before grief catches up, and he says he still wears his wedding ring as a reminder of her. Ramsey then asks Carter about growing up with Rachel as a family presence despite never meeting Rachel, leading Sherry to discuss her hidden pregnancy and the family's struggles and hopes around Carter's birth.

The next clip, from January 2009, shows young Annabel at Grandpa's house on the day Charlie is acquitted. Jeff explains that Charlie had spent seven months in custody awaiting trial, and the verdict of not guilty finally allowed Charlie to come home. The footage shows Charlie tearfully reuniting with Annabel and promising never to leave her again, while the present-day family reflects on how Sherry, Jeff, and Grandpa cared for Bel and newborn Carter during that period.

The filming briefly turns chaotic when Jeff leaves for the bathroom while still wearing his microphone, and Charlie lightens the mood by telling an embarrassing story about Bel ruining his beloved truck years later. Ramsey then tries to question Grandpa Patrick about the trial, but Patrick's dementia leaves him confused and distressed. Patrick lashes out at Charlie, and Charlie gently explains that Patrick's strokes and vascular dementia have erased many memories, including much of the time Rachel was part of the family.

Ramsey plays what may be the last video of Rachel before the mall security footage, recorded by Rachel two days before she disappeared. In it, Rachel lovingly tickles toddler Annabel and calls Bel a mommy's girl before Charlie enters and notes that Rachel left the front door open again. Bel is uncomfortable seeing apparent love from Rachel because Rachel still vanished and left Bel behind, and Ramsey and Jeff observe that Bel now sounds strikingly like Rachel.

Ramsey asks Charlie about testimony from the trial describing Rachel as forgetful and distracted before her disappearance. Charlie lists incidents such as leaving doors, ovens, faucets, windows, the baby monitor, and even Bel in the bathtub, though he attributes it to stress or baby brain. Bel privately notices uncomfortable similarities between Rachel's forgetfulness and her own habits, then deflects Ramsey's question about what she would say if Rachel returned; Charlie answers instead that he would hold Rachel and tell her he loves and misses her before asking questions.