Bel goes to Ash’s hotel room after Ash says he and Ramsey have found something. Ramsey leaves Bel and Ash alone, saying a filmmaker should know when not to get in the way, while Ash explains that his documentary footage is being stored and kept separate until they know what they have.

Bel receives a call from Dave Winter about Charlie’s phone records. Dave says Charlie made one brief call at 3:20 a.m. the night he disappeared, and the call pinged near Danville, Vermont. The number belongs to Robert Meyer, who lives outside Barton, Vermont, a name Bel does not recognize; Dave has already asked Rachel, who also claimed not to know him.

Dave says Charlie’s phone has been off since that call, and that there have been more hits on Charlie’s bank card. Bel considers telling Dave about Julian Tripp and the $3,000 but decides not to, wanting Dave focused on finding Charlie while Bel handles Rachel herself. Bel asks Dave to call her first with updates instead of Rachel.

After refusing Carter’s request for a sleepover, Bel turns back to Ash’s discovery. Ash starts recording and plays audio from the dinner party, explaining that Charlie said nothing useful before turning off his microphone, but Jeff forgot his microphone was still live when he helped Grandpa into the car.

In the recording, Jeff urgently asks Grandpa to remember something, asking where “she” was and where “they” found her. Grandpa cannot answer and asks for Yordan. Bel and Ash conclude Jeff was probably asking about Rachel, meaning Jeff believes Grandpa knows something about Rachel’s disappearance or reappearance.

Ash connects the recording to Julian Tripp’s comments about Rachel being scared and mentioning Jeff. Bel realizes there are more secrets buried within the Price family, especially around Jeff and Grandpa. Because Jeff appears to be hiding what he knows, Bel decides she will make him tell her the truth the next day.