The documentary crew stages a reenactment of Rachel Price’s disappearance on the same road where Bel was found, using fake snow and a matching blue Honda Accord. Ramsey presents the setup as accurate and asks Bel to say if it is too strange; Bel says it is, but filming continues. Ash, assigned to shoot behind-the-scenes footage, talks with Bel and shows her tattoos representing his mother, sisters, himself, and Ramsey, creating a brief, awkward connection.

A car arrives carrying Jenn, the actress playing Rachel. Because Jenn is dressed like Rachel on the day of the disappearance, Bel initially freezes and mistakes the image for Rachel herself. Ramsey admits he assumed Bel understood an actress would be present, and Bel resents the lack of warning. Jenn’s fascination with the case and casual manner immediately anger Bel.

Bel is then asked to sit in the backseat of the replica car while Jenn sits silently as Rachel. Ramsey explains that the sequence will intercut young Bel from the reenactment with present-day Bel describing what might have happened. Bel is uncomfortable but answers Ramsey’s questions, saying she remembers nothing from being two years old but knows Julian Tripp found her in the running car, warm and unharmed, with Rachel’s coat and purse left in the front.

Ramsey reviews the conditions of the disappearance: the freezing weather, Rachel’s missing coat, and the sniffer dogs that tracked Rachel’s scent about thirty yards before losing it in the road. Bel pushes back against theories that a caring abductor left the heat on for her, suggesting the car was already running, the doors were shut for practical reasons, or Rachel herself left Bel behind without intending Bel to die.

The interview shifts to public obsession with the case and Phillip Alves, a man who fixated on Rachel’s disappearance. Bel explains that Alves once impersonated a police officer to question Jeff and Sherry, then years later abducted eight-year-old Bel from school by pretending to be an officer. Alves demanded that Bel remember who took Rachel, but Bel knew nothing; Police Chief Dave Winter found her within minutes, and Alves was later convicted. When Ramsey says the crew is trying to contact Alves, Bel’s only message is, "Fuck you."

During lunch, Bel overhears Jenn and Louise gossiping about the case. Jenn says she thinks Charlie killed Rachel and pities Bel’s sad life. Enraged by the crew’s assumptions and by feeling like a prop in someone else’s story, Bel throws a chip packet at Jenn and storms into the trees. Ash follows and asks where she is going, but Bel snaps at him, and he backs off.