Thursday Murder Club, #1
The Thursday Murder Club
by Richard Osman
Contents
Chapter 71
Overview
The club has Austin examine the hidden skeleton and learns that it is far newer than Sister Margaret’s 1874 burial, likely only several decades old. The stripped remains suggest a deliberate concealment, turning the grave into another unresolved mystery tied to the present investigation.
Elizabeth persuades the group to keep the discovery from the police until Austin can learn more, reinforcing the club’s habit of pursuing evidence on their own terms. Bogdan’s unease highlights the legal and moral risk of their secret investigation.
Summary
At the grave opened on the morning of Ian Ventham’s murder, Bogdan sets up an arc light so the group can examine the extra skeleton found above Sister Margaret’s coffin. Austin climbs down with Ibrahim’s help, while Elizabeth, Joyce, Ron, Bogdan and Ibrahim watch.
Austin inspects the bones and, speaking cautiously, says the remains have been buried for a considerable time. When Joyce notes that Sister Margaret’s headstone is dated 1874, Austin rules out the skeleton being that old and estimates the burial as perhaps thirty, forty or fifty years old, depending on the soil.
Ibrahim concludes that someone must have reopened the grave, hidden another body inside, and filled it in again. Elizabeth asks whether the remains might belong to another nun and whether any jewellery or clothing survives, but Austin finds nothing: the body appears to have been stripped bare, suggesting that if this was murder, the killer acted deliberately and carefully.
Austin asks to take some bones away for closer examination in the morning, and Elizabeth agrees. Bogdan asks whether they should now tell the police, but Elizabeth argues that they should wait until Austin can identify more, because police involvement might cut off the club’s access to the evidence.
Bogdan voices concern that their behaviour is not normal and that he may be the one sent to prison if the plan fails. Joyce, Ibrahim and Elizabeth reassure him in their own ways, and Elizabeth says they only want to learn whose remains these are and who buried them. The group agrees to keep the discovery quiet for now, help Austin out of the grave, collect the bones, and return to Joyce’s for tea.
Who Appears
- ElizabethDirects the secret grave investigation and argues against telling police yet.
- AustinExamines the hidden bones and estimates they are several decades old.
- BogdanProvides access and lighting, then worries about the group’s risky secrecy.
- IbrahimHelps Austin into the grave and reasons out how the body was hidden.
- JoyceObserves the examination and supports Bogdan by admitting the group is not normal.
- RonWatches from the churchyard, drinks Stella, and jokes familiarly with Elizabeth.