Late at night, Garrett texts Hannah that he needs to talk and then reveals he is already outside her dorm. His tense, emotionless manner makes Hannah fear something happened with his father, but once they are alone in her room, Garrett immediately asks whether she is going out with Justin that weekend.

Hannah admits Justin did ask her out and that she said yes, but she explains she has not decided whether she will actually go. When Garrett learns Justin asked before Hannah and Garrett slept together, he briefly relaxes, but he becomes angry again when Hannah says she is still undecided. Hannah pushes back by reminding Garrett that they are not officially dating and have only been fooling around.

That challenge forces Garrett to say what he wants more directly. He argues that his priorities have changed and suggests he wants Hannah to be his girlfriend. Hannah, however, is caught off guard. Because she never expected their arrangement to become a real relationship, she admits she has not thought through what they are or where things might lead.

Hannah’s uncertainty hurts Garrett deeply because he already sees their connection as something serious and meaningful. He starts to say more, then stops himself. Instead, Garrett bitterly reduces his role to being Hannah’s "sex therapist" and "fluffer," accusing her of using him to get ready for Justin.

Hannah objects, insisting that Justin asked her out before she and Garrett slept together and that she likely was not going to accept the date anyway. Garrett, still feeling rejected and used, tells Hannah to go on the date and leaves in anger, slamming both doors behind him. After he is gone, Hannah realizes she likely understands what their relationship means after all, and she fears her hesitation may have ruined it.