Hannah and Garrett arrive at Garrett’s townhouse in a rush of desire, and Hannah immediately tries to push past their usual caution. Garrett slows her down, insisting on the "baby steps" he has set for them, even while making it clear that he wants her just as much. Their teasing banter eases Hannah’s nerves and keeps the moment playful rather than frightening.

As they undress and kiss, Hannah notices an important difference between Garrett and Devon: Garrett does not treat her like she is breakable. When Garrett moves lower, Hannah briefly flashes back to similar moments with Devon, but Hannah deliberately pushes those thoughts away and chooses to stay present. Garrett checks that she is comfortable before continuing, and his care and patience allow Hannah to relax into the experience.

Garrett brings Hannah to orgasm through oral sex, something no previous partner has done. The experience overwhelms Hannah so completely that she starts crying afterward, then admits that the tears come from happiness rather than pain. Garrett quickly turns the awkwardness into humor, reassuring Hannah while also enjoying the proof that she is responding to him in a new way.

Hannah then focuses on Garrett, undressing him and exploring his body while they joke and flirt. She performs oral sex on him and brings him to climax, and afterward Hannah asks if they can finally have intercourse now that she knows she can orgasm with him. Garrett still refuses to rush that step, sticking to his plan of moving carefully despite the progress they have made.

Tucker calls Garrett to leave for hockey practice, so Garrett hurriedly gets dressed and asks Hannah to stay at the townhouse until he returns. Alone, Hannah reflects on how significant the afternoon feels, especially after months of frustration with Devon. Instead of overthinking whether she is now "fixed," Hannah decides to make herself useful and comforting: she explores the kitchen, calls her mother for Nana’s lasagna recipe, and starts cooking dinner for Garrett and the other hockey players, signaling how much more at home she feels in Garrett’s life.