If He Had Been with Me, #2
If Only I Had Told Her
by Laura Nowlin
Contents
Jack — Fifteen
Overview
Jack spends two disciplined weeks numbing grief with academics and routines, resisting social life. A chance encounter with Brett’s tears reveals Brett’s twin, Todd, died years ago. Jack discloses Finn’s recent death, and the roommates share losses over dinner. Their guarded rapport begins, and Brett offers hope that memories will someday hurt less.
Summary
Two weeks into college, Jack throws himself into classes and a rigid schedule to avoid thinking about Finn. He attends lectures, studies in the library, runs at night, and eats at off-hours to stay isolated. He brushes off attempts at conversation, even from a girl he might have welcomed under other circumstances, and lies to his worried parents about making friends.
One afternoon, with no pressing work, Jack calls home, fields more concern about friends, then returns to the dorm early. He finds Brett crying over a framed photo. Expecting denial, Jack instead hears Brett apologize and confess that his twin brother, Todd, died when they were fourteen, which has made sharing a room painful.
Brett describes Todd’s talents in acting, love of baseball, and generous spirit, and how a freak traffic collision led to Todd’s death. Moved, Jack reveals that Finn died last month and explains Finn’s careful nature, kindness, soccer skill, and recent relationship. They acknowledge how death shattered their former belief in their own invulnerability.
Jack skips his run to eat with Brett; over pizza they talk about grief and memory. Brett assures Jack he will never forget Finn and that, in time, some memories will bring happiness without overwhelming pain. Their conversation eases the tension between them.
As they head back, Brett reiterates that someday remembering will not only hurt. In the elevator, he jokes about Jack judging his JV baseball photo, and they both laugh. They are not instant friends, but a genuine start is made.
Who Appears
- JackNarrator; isolates through strict routines, confides about Finn’s death, and begins opening up to Brett.
- BrettRoommate; found crying, reveals his twin Todd died at fourteen, connects with Jack over shared grief.
- FinnJack’s best friend who recently died; Jack recalls his caution, kindness, soccer skill, and packed funeral.
- Todd CarterBrett’s twin; talented actor and baseball lover, died in a freak collision causing airbag failure.
- Carole (Mom)Jack’s mother; worried on calls, presses him to make friends and asks about his routine.
- DadJack’s father; joins the call, urges balance beyond grades, shares parental concern.