Pip conducts a second recorded interview with Naomi Ward after Elliot Ward tells Pip that Andie Bell had cyber-bullied another girl in their year. Naomi identifies the girl as Natalie da Silva, a pretty blonde student whom Naomi believes Andie saw as competition for male attention.

Naomi explains that Andie spread cruel sexual rumours about Natalie and publicly humiliated her. During the Easter holidays, Andie and others allegedly used Chris Parks or Chris Parks's phone to trick Natalie into sending a topless video, believing she was sending it privately to Chris. The video was then shared widely online, and Natalie was devastated enough to miss the first two days of school after the break.

Pip asks whether Sal knew, and Naomi says Naomi mentioned it to Sal. Sal disapproved but refused to get involved, calling it Andie's drama. This complicates Sal's image because Sal knew about Andie's cruelty but remained passive.

Naomi then reveals another incident from the autumn term. Natalie received a lead part in the sixth-form play, a role Andie wanted. Andie allegedly threatened Natalie by claiming that Daniel da Silva, Natalie's older brother and a former part-time school caretaker, had had sex with Andie when Andie was fifteen. Andie said she would report Daniel for statutory rape unless Natalie dropped out of the play, so Natalie quit out of fear.

Pip asks whether Andie's claim about Daniel was true, but Naomi does not know. Naomi says Natalie is back living with her parents and that she heard Natalie was later arrested, charged with ABH, and spent time in prison. Pip asks Naomi for Natalie's phone number, making Natalie the next likely witness in the investigation.