Dear Debbie
by Freida McFadden
Contents
Chapter 40
Overview
A draft Dear Debbie response shows Debbie advising a distressed wife whose husband insults her cooking. After offering briefly normal suggestions, Debbie recommends poisoning the husband with antifreeze, revealing how openly her advice-column persona has become a vehicle for lethal impulses.
Summary
The chapter appears as an entry from Debbie’s draft files rather than a conventional scene. A reader calling herself Hopeless in the Kitchen writes to Debbie because her husband mocks her cooking, calling her possibly the worst cook in the country, even though the reader and her children think the meals taste fine.
Hopeless in the Kitchen explains that she has tried new recipes, online tutorials, and emotional effort to become the cook she believes her husband deserves. Her main conflict is not the food itself, but her distress over disappointing a husband whose judgment she treats as superior.
Debbie’s response begins with ordinary advice: take a cooking class and ask the husband to cook for the family so he can demonstrate what he likes and appreciate the work involved. The advice then turns malicious when Debbie suggests adding ethylene glycol, or antifreeze, to the husband’s food because it tastes sweet and will stop his complaints.
The draft reinforces Debbie’s dangerous mindset by presenting poisoning as domestic advice. It also connects to the broader pattern of Debbie using her advice-column voice to justify harm under the appearance of helpfulness.
Who Appears
- DebbieWrites a draft advice response that turns domestic frustration into a poisoning suggestion.
- Hopeless in the KitchenLetter writer distressed because her husband mocks her cooking despite her efforts.
- Hopeless in the Kitchen’s husbandCriticizes his wife’s cooking and becomes the target of Debbie’s lethal advice.