Cover of If He Had Been with Me

If He Had Been with Me

by Laura Nowlin


Genre
Young Adult, Romance, Contemporary, Fiction
Year
2013
Pages
368
Contents

Chapter 27

Overview

Autumn navigates school attention over her black eye while Alex popularizes a tidy accident story. Sylvie unexpectedly approaches Autumn to be "friendly," which Autumn later realizes was prompted by Finny. The reveal that Finny and Sylvie are back together reasserts distance between Autumn and Finny even as he protects her reputation.

Summary

On Monday, Autumn’s black eye becomes a spectacle at school. She and Jamie stick to a carefully shaped version of the sledding accident, and Alex theatrically retells it to classmates, which helps fix the narrative and deflect suspicion. As the bruise fades, remarks shift from curiosity to commentary, leaving Autumn exhausted by week’s end.

On Friday, Autumn encounters Sylvie alone in the restroom. Sylvie greets her, compliments the healing bruise, and says she is trying to be friendly. When pressed only by implication, Sylvie admits Finny asked her to be friendly to Autumn. Confused but compliant, Autumn agrees they can be friendly and leaves.

At lunch, Autumn mentions Sylvie’s approach but withholds that Finny prompted it, so her friends cannot decipher the meaning. The truth clicks when Autumn enters Mr. Laughegan’s class and sees Sylvie perched on Finny’s desk, their fingers intertwined as they talk and laugh.

Autumn realizes Sylvie’s friendliness signaled a reconciliation with Finny. She notes with a small leap of feeling that Finny does not like his girlfriend attacking or spreading rumors about her. The confirmation lands as Sylvie kisses Finny, and Autumn pointedly turns to reading, absorbing that their renewed relationship reinstates a boundary between her and Finny.

Who Appears

  • Autumn
    Narrator; manages gossip about her black eye, meets Sylvie, and discovers Finny and Sylvie are back together.
  • Sylvie
    Approaches Autumn to be friendly at Finny’s request; later seen reunited and affectionate with Finny.
  • Finny
    Back at school; asks Sylvie to be kind to Autumn; reconciles with Sylvie, confirming distance from Autumn.
  • Alex
    Friend who dramatizes the sledding collision story, shaping the school’s understanding of Autumn’s bruise.
  • Jamie
    Autumn’s boyfriend; part of the agreed story about the sledding accident causing her black eye.
  • Mr. Laughegan
    English teacher; present as Autumn observes Finny and Sylvie together in his classroom.
© 2026 StoriLuna